30 October 2026
A Bavarian supplement manufacturer used three rice extracts as flow agents in tablets and capsules, in place of magnesium stearate. The manufacturer considered them processing aids. Following a notification through the Rapid Alert System for Food and Feed (RASFF), the Bavarian authorities challenged the use of these substances as unauthorized food additives. They argued that
- The rice extracts were being used as unauthorized food additives, as they were functioning as anti-caking agents under Annex I No. 8 of Regulation (EC) No 1333/2008; and
- They could not be classified as processing aids because the entire quantity added during manufacturing remained in the final product rather than leaving only an unintended, technically unavoidable residue.
The manufacturer challenged that position, arguing that the substances were used as processing aids because:
- The rice extracts served a mechanical and temporary purpose during the filling process; and
- They exerted no technological effect on the final product.
After losing in the first instance before the Administrative Court of Bayreuth (VG Bayreuth) [1], the manufacturer appealed to the Bavarian Higher Administrative Court (BayVGH).[2] By a request dated 2 July 2026, the BayVGH asked the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) to interpret Article 3(2)(a) and (b) of Regulation (EC) No 1333/2008 on food additives.[3] The questions concern the criteria for distinguishing between two legal categories that determine the requirements applicable to the use of substances during food manufacture. The Commission published the request on 26 October 2026 as Vital Products (C-727/26).[4] It asks two things:
- Must an additive still have a technological effect on the final product, and, if not,
- Must a processing aid be removed as far as possible after use?
Article 3(2) of Regulation (EC) No 1333/2008 defines a food additive and a processing aid as follows:
- Food additive: any substance not normally consumed as a food in itself and not normally used as a characteristic ingredient of food, whether or not it has nutritive value, the intentional addition of which to food for a technological purpose in the manufacture, processing, preparation, treatment, packaging, transport or storage of such food results; or may be reasonably expected to result, in it or its by-products becoming directly or indirectly a component of such foods.
- Processing aid: any substance which (i) is not consumed as a food by itself; (ii) is intentionally used in the processing of raw materials, foods or their ingredients, to fulfil a certain technological purpose during treatment or processing; and (iii) may result in the unintentional but technically unavoidable presence in the final product of residues of the substance or its derivatives provided they do not present any health risk and do not have any technological effect on the final product;
Article 2(2)(a) excludes processing aids from the regulation unless they are used as additives.
Article 18(1)(b)(iii) allows carry-over of an additive that has no technological function in the final food, which only makes sense if the additive concept itself does not demand one.
Four differences matter.
First, the substance: an additive must also not be normally used as a characteristic ingredient, a condition the processing aid definition lacks.
Second, the verbs: additives are added to food, processing aids are used in processing. Some German courts (such as the OVG Lüneburg in 2010 case 13 ME 85/10 [5]) read this as meaningful, while the VG Bayreuth rejected it.
Third, and decisive, is what remains in the food. An additive may become a component in any quantity, while a processing aid may leave only unintentional, technically unavoidable residues without technological effect on the product.
Fourth, the legal consequence: an additive must be on the Union list in Annex II, and food containing an unauthorized additive cannot be marketed, whereas a processing aid is outside the regulation and needs no authorization.
The definitions can also overlap. Article 2(2)(a) and the carry-over rules show that a substance can be an additive without any effect in the final product. The Pfanni judgment (C-144/93) pointed the same way under the old labelling rules, but it predates Regulation 1333/2008, so it is support and not proof.[6] The opposite view, for example, the Styrian administrative court in 2023, treats the effect in the final product as decisive.[7] That is a real position, and the Court could follow it.
Applied to C-727/26, we can expect the Court to answer no to the first question. Article 3(2)(a) ties the technological purpose to the manufacture, processing or storage of the food, not to the finished product, and asks only that the substance becomes a component of it. The “no technological effect” wording in the processing aid definition proves little, because it cuts both ways and VG Bayreuth rejected the reverse inference. The Regulation’s structure, as shown above, points the same way.
On the second question, we can expect the Court to reject a free-standing removal requirement but to reach a similar result through the text. Article 3(2)(b) covers only “unintentional but technically unavoidable” residues. A substance that stays in the quantity added is not an unintentional residue, as VG Bayreuth reasoned, so it falls under the additive definition. Removal as far as technically possible is then evidence that a residue was unavoidable, not a separate condition. The Court may also reformulate the question or, as in Micreos (C-745/22)[8], leave it unanswered.
The conclusion is clear and simple: an additive becomes part of the food in the quantity added and needs Union-list authorisation. A processing aid may leave only unintentional, technically unavoidable residues without technological effect and needs no authorisation.
References:
- VG Bayreuth, Gerichtsbescheid v. 21.11.2023 – B 7 K 23.35
- VGH Munich, 02.07.2026, 20 BV 23.2212
- Regulation (EC) No 1333/2008
- CJEU, 02.07.2026, C-727/26, Vital Products
- OVG Lüneburg, 08.2010, 13 ME 85/10
- CJEU, 28.09.1994, C-144/93, Pfanni judgment
- LVwG Steiermark, 14.04.2023, LVwG 30.11-6218/2022
- CJEU, 22.02.2024, C-745/22, Micreos Food Safety

